Being British

I was born in Enfield, Middlesex on 22nd November (St Cecilia's Day), 1941. I doubt whether I could answer questions being asked of would be British citizens in the now compulsory test that has to be taken. The government worries that people living in Britain are "not integrated". (The Government "Fact" booklet includes where Father Christmas is supposed to come from!)

What knowing answers to the arcane questions has to do with integration is hard to tell. Certainly in this version integration is a one-way traffic. The rest of the nation can continue quite happily without knowing why others are here. When this was put to those from Britain's former colonies a response was "we are here because you were there".

Last night (2/11/2005) I attended a function at the Birmingham Council House organised by the Sikh Community and Youth Service based on Soho Road in Handsworth. This was to celebrate the Sikh contribution to World War II. Given the relatively small number of people involved their sacrifice was immense. The Lord Mayor was present as was a military band complete with their scarlet tunics and bear skin helmets. (Someone is asking that the bear skin be replaced by artificial fibre - can't be British surely?). It was intended that the ceremony should take place in Victoria Square, but rain forced it to take place on the Council House steps whre the band huddled together. I wasn't expecting them to break into "Sing, Sing, Sing" with their Gene Krupa on drums having a field day. They then broke into a nostalgic medley including "Run Rabbit Run", Roll out the Barrel" and "Lilli Marlene".

As we walked up the stairs to the reception in the Banqueting Suite we passed two youg Sikhs, a boy and a girl with the large bhangra drums (dhol).

There were several veterans present including Sikhs and British officers who had served in the Indian army. I toolk the opportunity to raise with a senior army officer and event that Oscar Stewart (well known as a member of the Singing Stewarts in the 1960s)told me about. He had taken a group of African Caribbean young people to the Edinburgh Military Tattoo a few years back. During the proceedings the M.C. asked who was there from Australia. There was a huge response of shouting and cheering. Whose's from Canada? New Zealand? South Africa? They waited to hear who was from the Caribbean. It didn't happen so they cheered themselves. Neither was India mentioned. An incident in Canada in 1993 illustrates clearly how discrimination overrides any wish to honour service, devotion and sacrifice.

The idea of institutional racism is routinely denied. You must integrate if you are to live in Britain. Many people from other parts of Europe, the Irish, have done that by changing names and moving out of close-knit communities into anonymity in the suburbs. Who knows? If you are a "visible minority" you can do that, but your presence is still obvious. Has the "integrationist" lobby ever given a moments thought to the ridiculous situation they are inventing? Do they begin to understand the realities of life away from their ivory towers where some idiot has dreamed up a "cricket test" to exclude would-be settlers?

As we descended the Council House stairs after celebrating the heroism of one section of the community (there were many others from other parts of the commonwealth and elsewhere. I thought of the Muslim Noor Inyat Khan, murdered by the Gestapo who had gone to France as a radio operator like Odette) the dhol players continued their drumming. I spoke to the piper who had been playing upstairs saying stupidly "you've got opposition". Next I knew bagpiper and dhol players had got together. The combination was convincing and highly effective. My supposition of cultures in conflict was rudely banished into oblivion. Here was two way traffic indeed!

Posted by John Tyrrell at November 2, 2005 10:04 AM

Comments

Hi John,
Good to find a blog that's thoughtful and informative and on "the side of the angels"(i.e. humans) so to speakk.
I agreed with your comments on the new leadership of the Israeli Labour Party(just when it looked hopeless, a pleasant surprise), and found the reports on Bethlehem interesting. Palestninian Christians risk being crushed between Israeli oppression and Islamic militancy, and like many examples of Palestinian steadfastness that doesn't conform to stereotypes, theirs can be neglected by the media. (Witness the non-violent resistance at Bilin, which I'm still waiting to see on our television).
I also liked your thoughtful comments on those forgotten in war commemorations, and the onus politicians put on minorities to "integrate". I just found a website dedicated to the memory of prisoners of war killed when a Japanese ship was bombed by the Americans. I was delighted that a relative of mine, Captain Mark Gordon Braham, was commemorated. His Mum, and mine, would have been somewhat gratified. Only trouble is, my Mum's cousin Mark has, like all the others, a large Christian cross above his name. But Mark was Jewish, as I'm sure were some of the others. I want to thank the fellow who has created this website, it is very tasteful and I'm sure well-meant. But if I complain about the cross, I'm being fussy (and after all I'm not even religious). If I say nothing, the impression is left for anyone looking that all the unfortunate prisoners who died were Christians, as though no one else served in the war. Guess that's what some call "integration"!

Blogged by Charlie Pottins at November 21, 2005 3:47 PM

Hi Again, John,

Just to say that I have heard from John Taylor who created the Roll of Honour for the Hell Ship prisoners, and he tell sme that the cross he used was the Changi Cross, made by a prisoner in Changi jail, Harry Stogden, so really a symbol of their enduring spirit rather than any crusading zeal to conquer.
I've accepted this, and realising it might not be easy or desirable to try and separate the men out, suggested perhaps a note would suffice explaining that not all the men who died were Christians, though they served and died together.

Oh, BTW, I forgot, Happy Birthday!

Blogged by Charlie Pottins at November 24, 2005 11:40 AM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)